FEEDBACK
What they say about quality and performance! Just a few of the reports......read on!
The Base Dipole

Hi, when I came around to see you I was impressed to see the G Whip base antenna in action, if I recall the antenna was only about 6 feet off the ground and connected to an FT817 and you worked an OK station at S9 both ways with 2.5 watts. The absence of an ATU made me realise that I have fallen into bad habits over the years, tending to rely on Auto ATU’s to cover all eventualities.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Geoff, Despite the cold and a garden full of
melted water, snow and mud I couldn't resist trying the GWB today - especially after all the effort you put into speeding along
the build, testing and delivery in what must have been the worst weather of
the winter! The supplied personalised test results for my antenna was
a real surprise, but given the attention to detail and solid build quality
it was the icing on the cake and a
great boost in confidence that all was well and it would work. Which it
certainly did - in the limited time I had to run a test it tuned on 80
and on 17 with minimal fuss and on 17, I worked a couple of East coast
State-side stations receiving 59 and 56 reports back (59 and 57 with me)
and then 59 both ways from Bosnia. The only problem I had was the proximity
to the large trees and shrubs in the garden which had an
impact on tuning at different heights as it's difficult to get the antenna
in the clear - this shouldn't be a problem when I can get out /P which was
the main reason for getting the antenna. Roll on the warmer days!
Thanks for a great piece of kit. Kevin. M0KSJ...............thanks Kevin.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Today, I had a contact
with a VA station near Quebec. Contact was initially made using my
Comet H422 (in a V format) at 20 feet using a barefoot FT2000. During the
QSO I switched to my G Whip base antenna which was also at 20 feet without
any noticeable difference in signal strength in either direction. An
amazing performance for an antenna about ½ the length of the Comet!
--------------------------------------------------------------------
My friend, the G Whip commercial base antenna is good for us, we are Shell oil and use the allocation here in Africa on 4MHz - 5MHz, we try Codan, we try Q Mac, but G Whip is best results, best quality, solid antenna....................... Thank you.......Nadir. Shell Oil Africa Office
--------------------------------------------
Very pleased with the unit especially on 160 Mtrs, like listening and have no big garden to put up a long-wire, if you use the centre only it is fabulous for general short-wave coverage with the 7Mhz coils, only 15 foot long........Peter Grimsby. Cambridge......PS want the loop antenna
----------------------------------------------------------------------
What quality! the build quality and components are superb and will last a lifetime. I worked lots on 80 Mtrs this week, really pleased and thanks for the FREE Top band coils and 70MHz whips, it is a bargain for the quality and results I am getting................Stephen G7 (callsign with held by request).
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mad selling it for this price, the engineering work that has gone into this aerial is brilliant, I used a fishing rod to do what you have done (and had to use a tuner) and it lasted about 10 days before it fell to the floor in bits, good luck with a truly superb British Product that I discovered in Practical Wireless......Joe Sillario
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
I was amazed at the quality! solid as a rock, I can change the system in seconds for different bands or frequency's.............Superb buy Alan Discole.
-----------------------------------------------------------
Geoff, I received mine beautifully packed, looked at it and it is just brilliant in construction, so, put it in the loft and set it up as per personalised spec-sheet, it was way out of resonance probably due to the rafters and other junk in the loft, after 2 hours up/down in the loft I finally got there, spot on VSWR @ 3.725 MHz @ 1.2 /1. works great and can also drop in the tuner if I want to move HF/LF,(don't shout at me as I know an antenna should always be resonant), it has given me operation on 80 which I never had before due to limited antenna restrictions outdoors.........tks Harry G3....(Callsign withheld at request)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Geoff,
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is antenna is just great...........................Pablo Avlavris PY7....(My Friend Fred bought it for me in the UK)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Geoff, all received ok, the packing was FAB, when I opened everything up I was amazed, wow is this built well or what? it is the best piece of amateur radio equipment I have ever purchased. I had lots of QSOs on 20 today, into the USA/Canada even to W5...................Thanks Douglas G3.....
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The huge package arrived today. WOW that's a very serious Tripod with some very serious packing. I was gob smacked.!! Next I put it together in seconds and I must say I am very impressed with the whole thing. Like the antenna it is rock solid and will last a life time.......Best Regards..............Tony G7OEM
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I have had great fun with this antenna this Summer season with Sporadic E on 28MHz and 50MHz, I have limited garden space, this unit is good and takes up so little space. I would like to buy another one for my holiday home in Spain..............73 Joel: France
------------------------------------------------------------
Geoff, Just a quick note to say thanks for the antenna - it's working well, and filling a gap in my capabilities very nicely indeed. Best 73, Andy GØJLX------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Backpacker:
Geoff
Hi Geoff, I thought just let you
know how the antenna is working , I have mounted it on a fibre glass
mast that goes from 7ft to to 33ft worked quite a lot of
stations on psk31 on 40 . I thought I would change coils this weekend and
go on 14MHz this evening. I have a 66ft doublet up at 33ft as well
,switching between the both I heard a state side station so went into the
garden turned your antenna north to south straight away rx
signal went from s9 to 20+ so I thought I would have ago.
Well 30 minutes of calling l but I got through W3JK in New York confirmed
my call and location and remember that's 10watts only, not bad, very happy
indeed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. Hope your well Geoff I will
send you some pictures of the setup soon....Gary
M6GJS
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Resonant End Fed Reports.
Resonant antennas, "simply the best", "a no compromise stealth antenna", "precise attention to detail"...................that is what the users say!
Hundreds of them!!!!
..............From the Master himself Frank Pardy "The G Whip man GW3DZJ" now back on the air.............
Hi Geoff, Just to let you know I put the 20m end fed up on the bungalow eves and as a sloper it worked fine. Got an S9 from Italy and worked a DL then a K1 and couple UA's on CW , heard a few VKs as well. The W1 at S9 plus 20 didn't come back to me though......perhaps cos his 4 Yagis on a 60ft tower was pulling in the other big boys on freq Hi! Only joking . Just got to get my stiff cw wrist going again after 50 yrs away from a key ( I was a telegraphist in RAF ), stand more chance qso,s that way. Thanks for the opportunity get back on air again, 73 Frank GW3DZJ
Report from Richard G4WFR....................I went out to the New Forest today as there is plenty of space to play radio & tested the G Whip resonant end fed antenna out. It worked very well & my first QSO was with VK4 this afternoon followed by other VK’s, 9M6 & YB4 plus East & West coast USA & some Europeans. I was using my TS2000 with 100W running off the car battery.

(Feed point at top of mast, sloping to ground, G Whip End Fed 20 Mtrs: NOTE: Mast not supplied)
Using a similar idea the
feed point can be mounted under the house gutter/eaves and sloped down the
garden
Hi Geoff, well got mine at last due to postal strike and I must say how well it is built and packaged, went upstairs and lobbed it out of the window, tied the connecting box to the gutter, connected the coax, went to the radio, found a clear spot put out a CQ and back came a VE7! Wow!!! Wife does even not know it's there!..Magic and a nice piece of kit! .....Mike G4
I have just bought a Zepp for 20 Mtrs, it is made by ??? and is the biggest piece of junk I have ever bought, yours however, is superb, Richard G4WFR is right! it is fantastic.
Superb! best antenna I have ever had for 20 Mtrs................Dennis Dyke The Netherlands
Allan G7VQV says................worked W7 on internet via gateway......then organised contact via RF mode and worked him direct! WOW and now I have the 40 mtr version as well.
Pete G3!!! had to laugh at this, a box, a wire, Went out /p on 20 mtrs..................holy moses! pile up after pile up, they thought I had a BIG amp, what a product and unbreakable wire............... G Whip you have a blinding product here.
Arrived yet??? Yes thank you, arrived at around 4 o'clock this afternoon, impressed with both packing and hardware. In almost indecent haste after unpacking and eating, put the 15mtr one up in lieu of a guy wire on the inv L antenna, checked the swr on the Autek and spot on.........Gave single call to ST2AR thru pile up....599, Then replied to a CQ from VE7SV.....single call again... 579 and during the chat was told I was one of the only European stns he could hear. Run the Pro 111 at about 90 watts, so it's looking promising.. Given decent wx tomorrow I'll try the other 2 and let you know how I get on. Give it a week or so to cover the vagaries of HF conditions. 73 Jack Batham G3LNC
What you can do with 5 watts and a resonant antenna.....................no tuner
We headed up the hills a few days before Christmas with a Yaesu FT-817 and a NorCal CW box. it was absolutely freezing so we fixed up a 10m pole attached to a farmers post and ran the 20m resonant end fed with the feeder along the ground. It may have been better with the box in the air but it was so cold we wanted fast results and we were set up and back in the car in minutes. We started with the 817 and were getting Italy, Hungary and Serbia with just 5 watts and good reports on the quality of our signal, and it was the same impressive stuff with the little NorCal. I’m sure there’s more to be had by experimenting with position although on the day we favoured the warmth of the car. Overall its 10/10 from me on construction, performance and ease of set up for mobile QRP use, without doubt it’s a quality bit of kit. Best Regards Dave 2W0DRB
What you can do with 10 watts and a resonant antenna.....................no tuner
G Whip resonant end fed antennas......................These are the proverbial “mutts nuts”!
I bought a 20m version, put it on a pole that was lying around my garage about 8ft long, cable tied it to my fence, pulled out the wire radiator & jammed it to the top of my fence (about 5ft high) without insulating it, checked VSWR and the needle hardly moved at all, I answered a CQ from North America at about lunch time using only my allowed 10w and got a perfectly acceptable 59 report straight back, then South France with 57! The antenna was between two houses, low down as I have said, and orientation not even considered. The engineering of these antennas is bullet proof, you can throw a line (included in the package) over a tree or tied to the roof of your house, or on a pole / tower / anything else handy for that matter, at home or portable, & be on the air in minutes without an ATU, perfectly resonant on the band, & not wasting power in a lossy ATU . The Zepp’s come packaged in a box approx 9” by 4” so don’t take up much room when not in use or transporting or you can leave up permanently as they are tested in storms etc and the radiator is green Kevlar so semi hidden in the air and also unbreakable and will last a lifetime. I have since been back and now have 5 of them (different bands). Why mess about with compromise antennas and suffer TVI when you can make life simple for yourself with a resonant end fed? Oh and another thing --- they are too cheap!!! (remember no ATU to buy). Geoff is so helpful also, he answered all my emails very quickly, even when out of the country in Japan, he offers his free advice on anything you care to ask about, with no obligation. I can’t praise these enough and have no hesitation in recommending them. They are not a beam, but don’t cost the same as a beam and so easy to put up (compared to a beam), and perform great too. Happy DXing 73 MM6RSP (restricted to 10w)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
GM0KCN......................
Can you please send me the 10mtr mini ef as the 20mtr you sent me is the best antenna that I ever used for QRP .......Thanks MM6TCH Shane. 73s
Geoff
Hi Geoff,
Hi Geoff,
FOLLOW UP>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Hi Geoff,
Report from Martin M0KZC below.....................
Said I'd give you some feedback on the End
fed antenna. I used the 20m version /P from my caravan whilst on holiday in
Cornwall and am very pleased. These antennas are ideal for /P working - easy and quick to erect, robust and with
good performance. Fed with 100W in 'sloper' configuration it easily
outperformed my multi band vertical both in terms of signal reports and, of
course, received noise. From an unpromising location I was able to work
around Europe and North America (when condx allowed) with solid 59 reports,
only VP8 was a 'getaway' owing to pile-up behavoir. I did initially attach
a tuner (just in case !) but didn't need it. You know what's coming
next................... I'd like to obtain another for 20m and others for 15
and 10m please. Martin M0KZC
Report from Keith GJ6TMM below......................
Last month i bought 2 Resonant End Feds
from
Geoff. 1 for 20m and 1 for 10m. I watched Geoff build them and test them on
air. When I got back to Jersey I did not have time to test them for a couple of
weeks. Since then i have tested them against my vertical multi band. Switching
between the vertical and the end fed my received reports went from 55 to 59+.
This evening i have called once to stations on 20m that were working
pileups and got through 1st time. JW ZB2 and HZ1.10m has been the same,1st or
2nd call and they come back to me. All I can say is i need more for the other
HF bands.
Thanks Geoff and Janet and GWHIP.......................GJ6TMM Keith
................As a relative newcomer to amateur radio, my first G-Whip order for a 10m end-fed was placed about a week before Christmas.
Geoff had just run out of ready-made units, but very kindly offered to build one from scratch.
Despite the madness of the Christmas time post, the antenna arrived,
sturdily packed, well before the festivities began. The quality is
outstanding and a credit to British-built equipment - and of course Geoff
himself. The Kevlar wire, though very flexible, really is amazingly
tough and I can't see any way this would ever fail - ideal for my
mountaintop QTH with its frequent 70mph gusts. And of course, the
beautifully-made matching unit only adds to the overall quality of these
units, as does the provision of all those bits - weatherproofing tape for the coax plug and socket, end insulator and suspension cords, and
even cable ties to secure the coax to the matching unit - that other
manufacturers typically leave out. All this for £45. With quality
and service like this, Geoff is clearly going to be getting plenty of
repeat business from me!
John Rowlands, MW1CFN. Finalist - BBC Radio 4 Amateur Scientist of the Year, 2010.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hi, Just to say that I managed Ukraine and Greece at the weekend, on 10mtrs with 5 watts. Your resonant end fed antennas do their stuff alright. Very pleased with them thanks. Best regards Brian, G7FAL.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hi Geoff, just a few lines to say that the resonant end fed arrived yesterday. I put it up an I am very pleased with it. I’ve not been on 17m before so to start with I am keeping the power down ( Hope not to cause any TVI ) – I will wind it up, bit by bit over the next few days or so. Anyhow on 10 watts i got in to 9H1 – UX1 – ER3 & I7, using cw & ssb. So I certainly would recommend anyone to buy this version of the end fed especially as vswr is very good.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
REMEMBER THAT THESE ANTENNAS ARE RESONANT END FEDS, NOT JUST A BIT OF WIRE
Geoff, I
feel I must write about the results on the G Whip Resonant End fed
antenna. We used one of these marvellous aerials while operating a
demonstration station over several weekends, All the aerials a mix of
verticals, dipoles and your 40M end feed, which were put up and taken down
each weekend, it was noticeable that with your aerial all we had to do was
connect the coax, put the box on the top of the 30 ft mast raise the mast
and tie the other end up in a tree, it was resonant and working! Not
so with the other aerials: up, down with the mast, adjust SWR!, all the
frustration of a demo station, but your aerial was resonant brand new out
of the box, we worked almost 1500 stations, most on your 40M end feed, I
have another at home, I had noted a GW0 trying with 400 watts to work a DK
station on 40M with a G5RV, however on the same band I was using your
aerial with just 10 watts I was working a group up and down the county,
with 59 reports -- cant think Why! PS how about an 80M version? Best 73
Andy G4MYS
Hello Geoff, Several months ago I purchased from you 3 End Fed Slopers 40, 20 & 17 Metres respectfully. Being Ex military I knew right away when I seen the Advert KEVLAR as the radiating element. Please add this to your Review page. I’m 2e0tvp Ken from Plymouth. Having installed the 40Mtr, end fed I got very good reports from around G Land. On the third day in the Morning on the Grey line placed a call out on 40 and got a response from ZL2OZ from New Zealand and we had a 15 min, QSO. The benefits of these antennas are Superb. Hopefully your order book from the South West has been quite busy , I have advertised the excellent quality of these Antennas. I was only running 50 Watts during the contact into ZL. Again thank you very much for your assistance and trouble free transaction …………Regards Ken 2E0TVP !! Very Satisfied Customer.!!
Hi Geoff. Just a quick update on the purchase of my antenna. As promised, the parcel arrived on Friday so thank you very much for your prompt service. Was hugely impressed with the packaging and everything arrived in tiptop condition. When I unpacked the product, again, I was really impressed with what you supply...rope for lashing the antenna, kite wrap for the antenna element. Even down to the cork protecting the hook! I didn't actually get around to installing the antenna until last night. I've attached the main box of tricks to the eaves of the house and strung the antenna wire down to my 25ft pole halfway down the garden, beaming west to east. I then attached my antenna analyser and was so impressed with the bandwidth...bang on the money for the voice part of 40M!!! Unit #402 was living up to expectations........I then hooked it up to my radio, tuned it to 40M and bammmm!!! I actually worked it out that between 7.090 and 7.195, i was hearing stations at every 3khz interval. Admittedly, conditions were good yesterday but your resonant antenna has definitely improved my setup. I put out a few CQ calls and was reaching mainland Europe and Inter G stations at 59/+10db signals with BBC quality audio on my allowed 10watts. It was a real pleasure to operate last night and I'm sure your antenna made a whole world of difference. I'm already planning on the installation of a 20M EndFed antenna so expect to see an order placed very soon. Keep up the good work Geoff :-) Paul.
From Gary G0DNI: As a previous customer of Geoff Brown (G4ICD) G Whip Antennas, I knew just where to go when I needed a portable antenna to go with my new Yaesu FT-817 QRP rig. I was looking for a no-fuss but highly efficient single-band (20M) antenna that I could use at home or in the field for some low power voice and data communications. I ordered the mini-end fed resonant antenna from Geoff, who as always immediately responded to my email request. The mini end-fed is a low power (50W max) lightweight version of Geoff's normal resonant end-fed and as such isn't intended to be permanently mounted outdoors, although it is finished to his usual high standard. Installation is as simple as hanging the box to a convenient point (from the upstairs window at the moment!) and running the radiator wire (about 10 meters long) down to the nearest suitable object. Everything that you need is included apart from the co-ax , so it doesn't take long to set up. Use in the field for portable operation would be just as simple, but with the box at ground level and the radiator elevated - opposite to my current setup. As the antenna is resonant on 20M, no ATU is needed, just plug the co-ax straight into the rig and you are good to go. I've only had the 20M mini end-fed for 3 days now and I have been primarily using data modes (PSK31 and JT65A) and learning how to drive the little FT-817. As the rig is working hard when sending data, I've set the output power to 2.5W as recommended by other users. So, how is the antenna performing? JT65A data mode is a very low power communication mode with signals being able to be decoded when they are almost inaudible to the human ear. With my 2.5 watts and the mini end-fed, I'm working well into Central Europe from the UK with my best contact so far being with an RA3 station just over 1700 miles away - actually this was my FIRST JT65A contact with the new rig/antenna setup - impressed, you bet! More routine contacts range from 500 to 1000 miles on JT65A with 2.5 watts. The beauty of the JT65-HF software is that it reports to the PSK Reporter network so it's possible to see just where your signals are being received. Remembering that this data mode is a very low power transmit and decode mode, PSK reporter has shown my signals being received in central USA and even one 'hit' in New Zealand. Sounds too good to be true? Go to the PSK Reporter website and do a search for 'signals sent by G0DNI' and see for yourself. Now, do I need the 40M mini end-fed too ......73 Gary G0DNI
Purchased the 20M version end fed yesterday at Didcot. Woke up this morning to find SNOW!!! Got the 20M G-whip end fed up this afternoon, as soon as the snow finished. Apart from freezing in the cold it was a snip to get up and working. A quick push of the on switch, change to correct frequency and BANG into Algeria over a 1000 miles away with 59 in both directions. I got in over the top of the German stations pushing out Kw of power into arrays and beams!! Why didn't I find these aerials sooner!!! They are going to be so easy and efficient for Special Event stations. Can't wait for the 40M and 60M versions now, it's like childhood Christmas all over again................Nigel Auckland M0NAF
I purchased a 20 meter G Whip End Fed Antenna
from Ian Ross in the UK. Ian was very responsive; he shipped my
order right away. The G Whip was very easy to install. However,
it was necessary to shorten the antenna to shift the frequency
up to cover the frequency of interest. Ian was very helpful and
explained how to make the change. It only took a few minutes.
The antenna is well made and it's nice to have a resonant
antenna for a change. I'm looking forward to making many
contacts with the G Whip antenna and my Patcomm PC-1600E.
Steve AA0MV
From Alan G0RTH:
Excellent 40m End Fed Antenna
Having had good experiences with both the G Whip Base antenna and
the G Whip mobile antenna I bought this 40m end fed as my inverted L
was OK on both 160m & 80m but not so hot on 40m. Superb
construction, easy to deploy and works very well. I had tried a
cheap competitor but the "matching box" wasn't in the same
league as Geoff's and it also didn't have the almost unbreakable
kevlar wire. A classic case of getting what you pay for - superb
engineering at a fair price. So impressed I've just ordered the 20m
and 6m versions.
Posted By
M0ZCM………….Still Excellent!
I thought that as I have now been using Geoff's antennas since I
started my Amateur radio journey in 2011, I would now do an update.
I currently own the following G Whip antennas:
20M EF
17M EF
Widebander
20M Mini EF
All of Geoff's antennas are of excellent quality and he clearly
takes a lot of pride in putting them together. In Operation they are
very simple to set up and work flawlessly. They have given me a lot
of hassle free enjoyment in the last two years not to mention some
great contacts.
If you live in a built up area like me, they present a low visual
impact, which in turn means less hassle for you. I have no
hesitation in recommending these antennas and will soon be buying a
40M band version.
I did promise to update my initial review after more use. Well firstly let me say I have now purchased both the 40M end fed and also the 60M (reviews to follow). I could not be more pleased with the 20M end fed. For example today I got Slovenia, some 800 miles away at 1500 (not a great time of day for 20M in my area) I was using Icom 74100 on 100W. The report back to me was 59 to 59+. My contact, S58WW, was putting 500W into a dipole and he was also getting 59+ from me. Another big advantage was the lack of noise when receiving a signal. My QTH is noisy with overhead power and telephone cables, plus broadband cables. I was getting 5 level noise until I tuned the signal - then nothing but clear audio. A pleasure to use. So easy to put up; and no problems from the neighbours as the green wire is almost invisible. I can get into US and Canada on 20M no problems. I have a pulley system to the chimney breast so I can drop the aerials quickly and easily, and they are connected using climbing type clips at both ends so I can have them down and in the car in 15 minutes to use them portable somewhere else. Thank you G Whip and RossComm for a great product.
M0AZE
Posted:
Posted
by 2E0STJ:
Posted by Martin M0KZC
Posted by M0HDF
The Widebander
(A TOP quality 9/1 balun Mil spec wound in IP rated box with a 20 mtr counterpoise and a 23 mtr kevlar sloper)
Allan, G7VQV comments: "had a good afternoon with it, was up at Cheese Foot Head, Nr Winchester on the road to Petersfield, and was working IOM, Denmark, Holland, Portugal etc on 20, 40 and 80 mtrs, and did hear the USA...............thanks Geoff.............You made my day"............PS: and today (29/8/2009) I worked the US and lots lots more..............checkout Allans website here
We have had over 50 5 star reports on this antenna, for the price it really is good based around it's optimum resonance of 7MHz, super on 7MHz, good on 14MHz, no good on 28 MHz (no propagation!) and does work on 3.6MHz.
Very pleased with the widebander, had my first qso on 160 mtrs, brill on 80 mtrs and even wkd a VK in Tasmania on 40 mtrs.
Geoff ...The Widebander is a fantastic piece of equipment I wanted to drop you a note to thank you for getting it out to me so quickly. It arrived a couple of days after placing the order well packaged and in perfect order as with all previous orders. The antenna is beautifully made opening the unun casing reveals a work of art I don’t think I have ever seen a commercially available amateur radio product so well put together. Performance is excellent the inbuilt ATU on my radio had no problems tuning the antenna on the bands I tried it on. I set mine up with the radiator sloping from the eaves of my house and the counterpoise a foot above ground level secured to a fence post. Very very pleased with the product many thanks Geoff again for all your help and advice. Thanks!..................Paul Jay
Hello Geoff.................I tried out the antenna on a few bands at the weekend when I had a minute or two. I had contacts on 10, 15, 20 & 40m. Best DX with my 5 watts were contacts with two east coast W's and a UA0 on 20m. I had a few contacts on 40m. This is a band that has proved difficult for this QTH. I was quite surprised as I worked DL, OZ, SM, OH & LA first call & no repeats. In total I worked 20 countries, mostly EU's. Didn't have time to get on 80m but I will try it sometime...................Dave, GM4HQF
This review is for the G Whip Wide-band end-fed antenna. (3.6Mhz to 50Mhz)........de
Gary G0DNI
Whilst I appreciate that there really isn't one antenna that works perfectly across the whole spectrum of the amateur bands, I have always had to balance practicality with visual impact. With this limitation my previous antenna of choice has been a full-size G5RV and I've had good results over the years with this simple setup. My current QTH (or should I say the aesthetics of the garden!) do not allow me to have the G5RV erected permanently and although my rig/derig time was down to 10 minutes, this was starting to get a bit tedious.
I was looking for another 'one antenna fits all bands' solution that would have a low visual impact, but still perform to a satisfactory level. I'm more than happy to grab DX when conditions are right, but my normal modus operandi is working UK nets on 80m and 40m and working a bit further into Europe on 20m. I use an Icom IC-706 and a Yaesu FT-757AT semi-automatic ATU that out lived the FT-757GX HF rig.
I came across the G Whip website www.gwhip.co.uk and was attracted by the high standard of construction of all the products and was tempted by the Wide-bander antenna. After a trawl around the web to read reviews an and exchange of emails with Geoff Brown (G4ICD) of G Whip Antenna Products an order was placed and the widebander arrived the next day.
Full details are on the G Whip website, but the widebander consists of a 9/1 un/un balun, approx 20m of kevlar radiator wire and a 20m kevlar counterpoise. Erection is simple, in my case the balun was strapped to a tree trunk next to the shack at about 4m AGL. the radiator is run through the trees, with one dog-leg through a pulley before being anchored to a smaller tree with a bungee. The counterpoise runs down from the balun and along the ground under the hedge line with the end being raised about
30cms. A short run of co-ax connects the balun to the ATU.
The widebander matches well from 80m (3.5Mhz) to 10m (28Mhz) but as my ATU has set bands that don't cover 6m (50Mhz) I can't match at 6m.
I've only been running the widebander for a couple of weeks and conditions haven't been particularly good - especially on 80m, but I'm very pleased with the results so far on 40 m and 20m. Using 100w from IO82, SSB contacts in addition to 'local' UK stations on 40m include:
South of France - F4FJZ
Latvia - YL2KF
Moscow - R3BA
Belarus - EW8QQ
Romania - YO5OHY
Croatia - 9A7DA
Germany - DD2CW
Portugal - CQ73I
Netherlands - PA/M1GEO/P
Spain - EA5ICU
Czech Republic - OK2MI
The conditions on 80m still continue to frustrate, but I have high hopes on this band too.
The best thing of all is that I had the antenna erected for a week before the XYL noticed it - and that was only because I used a red bungee to anchor to the low tree! The visual impact is so low that even I have to look hard to see it.
I will almost certainly invest in one of Geoff's band specific end fed antennas - maybe the 6m (50Mhz) model? (no ATU required!)
In summary, an excellent (and very affordable) replacement for my G5RV with performance that matches my needs.....Gary
G0DNI
Hi just to let you know how pleased I am with the multi-band longwire (Widebander) I purchased from you, I am an absolute beginner and live in a Bungalow in Mold, North Wales, I have a very small garden and limited space. I have run the longwire from a gable end to one corner of the small rear garden and then back to the chimney half way along the bungalow, at the point at the end of the garden the pole is only about 7 feet high but within hours of putting up the longwire - I was having a three way conversation with a friend in Birmingham and a chap in Dagenham on 40m and have had contacts in Romania, Hungary and Tenerief on 20m. I am in a valley and the longwire runs North / south so I never expected it to work so well . I am also very pleased with the quality of the components................Many thanks Bryan MW6BVT
Just a quick note to say how pleased I am with the
performance of my G Whip Widebander on 60M. I'm a new NOV holder (1 Jan 2013)
and have 'widebanded' both my Icom IC-706 Mk 1 and Yaesu FT-817ND. My first
experiments with 5MHz were using the IC-706 with the G Whip Widebander being
matched with an MFJ-904H manual ATU. The antenna matched exceptionally well
and running between 30 and 100 watts I received very positive comments during
the Sunday morning Combined Services net. I easily worked the other 5 stations
at ranges from 60 to 600 miles (OZ2).
Since widebanding the FT-817, this is now my rig of choice as it takes up less
space and the challenge of QRP is fascinating. I use the LDG Z817 auto ATU and
the G Whip Widebander works well with only 5 watts. Although it's early days
with the QRP rig, I've worked a couple of UK stations on the east coast and
south coast at ranges of around 150 miles, again with good reports.
Please feel free to use any of my comments on the website......73 Gary G0DNI
The Mobiles
Bicycle Mobile!....................Simon................G4SGI
.......Geoff,
Alan……….G0RTH.............
Dec 2012
I put the supplied tri-mag mount (optional extra) on my little Fiesta and
started to adjust the length of the top section always checking with my MFJ
analyser.
I found no problem in getting a VSWR of 1.5:1 or better across the whole of the
160m band (of particular interest as we have a local net on 1.908MHz AM on
Sunday afternoons and weekday evenings with a number of stations operating /M or
meeting up and operating /P from their cars and I want to join in this activity.
I'd previously tried a centre loaded antenna for this band (bought from a major
dealer) and using a similar tri-mag mount could NOT get any resonance except
above 1.950 MHz! So a definite improvement on that product, and, considering
there are coils and whips (with scans showing resonance & bandwidth) for
80/40/20 & 10m the cost isn't much different from purchasing 5 separate
antennas.
What is different and a lot better is the service from Geoff (I got an immediate
phone call reply to an email query) and the military standard build quality.
I'm looking forward to using this on the air this weekend on 160m and with the
other components inside the supplied plastic carry case (including spanner for
adjustment) in my boot I'm sure this system will get a lot of use during my
summer break in N Yorkshire and the Lake District.
I'll add another review after a longer period of use but 1st experience is good.
I have had this antenna for a while
now and have had some good results from limited activity.
Before placing the order I sent Geoff at G-Whip an email asking if I could swap
out the 160m could fit a 17m one as I don't use 160m. This was fine and after a
short wait the antenna arrived. The only reason for waiting a few extra days was
due to lots of orders having been placed at a rally the day before.
The antenna was well packed and came with high quality fittings and in itself is
very well made. Four band coils, a 3/8th mount, hefty ground strap, a whip
adjuster and 3 different size whips are provided along with SWR plots taken off
that actual antenna.
Setup was straight forward but care must be taken in making sure the mounting
point is study, the antenna is quite stiff and can put quite a bending force on
the base. I have it mounted on a bracket on my tow-bar fixing. The visual
profile is very good as well.
All in all I have yet to find anything I can fault it on, have worked around EU
and into the USA on 20m in moderate band conditions. Planning to get out and
about a bit more soon to keep the RF flowing into it. :-)
..................Ian M0PCB
The Baluns
Before you read the feedback look at "Rogues Corner" as somebody called it!
-----------------------------------------------------------
Wow G Whip what quality you offer, I bought a 4/1 from a well known business, what a heap of junk for £30.00, a made in China product I guess, but won't be going back there again, I do like my G Whip balun, it's a work of art.....Dave G4......

| Works well, NOBODY makes better baluns, made in the UK, puts others to shame | .................HiFissb eBay |
From Martin G8JNJ: I have known Geoff for some time, and all of his products are absolutely first rate quality, will withstand all sorts of abuse and will work as they are intended to. This is not surprising, as many GWhip products are based on tried and tested commercial designs, which have been sold in large numbers to various governments all around the world. GWhip Baluns and Ununs are unique in that they utilise special mix ferrite materials, which out perform many other types available to amateur constructors (and small scale manufacturers). PTFE covered wire and high grade materials are used throughout. In order to ensure consistent performance over many years of use. This can be verified from photographs showing detail of the construction, and in some cases individual measured performance plots, which are shown on the G Whip website.......www.gwhip.co.uk I just don’t understand why folks continue to buy cheap Baluns and Ununs wound on Iron powder (or similar) core materials that simply do not work properly. It would be hard to make your own version for the same price - Highly recommended......Martin G8JNJ
I bought the 4:1 balun to convert ladder line to coax. This one was one of the ex display models and has a clear perspex lid - showing incredible attention to detail & quality.....Highly recommended..............M5TAW
This product is built to military standards and I reckon would withstand a nuclear bomb. Puts other products at this price to shame. Comes complete with an individual frequency sweep and all the accessories to bond balanced to unbalanced together and fix it in a secure way. Ordered Saturday and delivered Monday. If only other Ham accessories were made this way! Check out the web site ...... www.gwhip.co.uk......Engineering at it's best! M0AZE
Sweep of 4/1 500 watt balun 2 MHz to 60MHz: Red trace is VSWR, Blue trace is return loss
Geoff, I received the 4:1
balun today, Well all I can say is wow build quality is great. makes the other
one I have look like a toy!
Just a couple of notes about the old one after removing the lid I found it full
of water! not sure how it got in but it has. Also because the toroid has been
forced into a box that is too small the output terminals have cut into the
windings so shorting them out. also all of the windings are very loose. know
wonder it was not working.! Give me a couple of days and I will get a picture to
you. Once again thanks for a great product I can now use my 20 meter loop on all
bands from 20 to 6 meters without an ATU. Cheers................John
Hi Geoff,
Received the balun ok yesterday thanks. I can match all bands now with my mfj
901b, the Snowdonia balun I had would only match a few bands and no connection
for counterpoise/earth. Used to have a triband beam years ago but just want a
smaller antenna to keep the neighbours happy and still be able to have a few
contacts and keep the cw going before i get rusty in my old age. Pity the band
conditions are very poor yesterday and today but managed a couple of qsos since
receiving it. I used to have the full set of G whip mobile coils in the late 60s
and they worked really well...Thanks...John.... G3VGU
| G4CZK
REPORT:
|
|||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Following a house move to Devon, I had to rethink my antenna options, and following several discussions with Geoff at G-Whip, I decided to purchase three of his 4:1 baluns and a Current Choke. Two of the 4:1 baluns are now used in my base antennas (a 3.5Mhz OCF dipole and a 320ft top doublet fed with open wire feeder. The current choke helps keep my portable vertical happy and all are subject to the gales and rain which we experience n this part of the world. The first thing I did when I received the baluns was to unscrew them to see what was inside (well, we all do that don't we!). The standard of manufacture was faultless - as was the attention to detail and there is no doubt that these units will probably outlast me and still look good at the end of it! All in all, given the time spent by Geoff on advising me about the various options, the obvious personal attention to detail during manufacture, and the speed of service, these baluns are incredibly good value, good quality, and they really work well. Like many others, I have bought cheaper baluns in the past, and have experienced the burn-outs/the water ingress/flashovers, etc of inferior quality units. These are different - VERY different indeed and the quality is reminiscent of some of the best products available when I was first licensed back in 1974. I can heartily recommend G-Whip products AND the service provided by Geoff Brown, the manufacturer. Oh, by the way - I have no connection with Geoff or with G-Whip - - I'm just a very demanding customer! | |||||
In need of a 1:1 Balun with legal limit rating I searched online looking at various suppliers to work out which would be the best quality and value for money. I quickly came to the conclusion that the G-Whip Balun ticked all the boxes. I emailed Geoff at G-Whip and he very quickly replied back advising me on the type of Balun and core suitable for my needs, description and photo. I ordered on the Friday night and received the Balun on Monday. First impressions were that this Balun was handmade to very high/military specs and was built to last. Inside the core was resin potted using PTFE coax and fitted with stainless steel hardware. Needless to say the Balun works very well as intended and I am very pleased with it. I can thoroughly recommend this G-Whip Balun, an excellent quality product at a very competitive price! No connection to G-Whip, just a very happy customer!....................Roger MW0IDX
Posted By SM4KAS
Superb product and service
First I bought the G Whip Receive Antenna with a 12/1 balun from Geoff (see my
review at www.gwhip.co.uk). After that I
asked Geoff if he could make me a balun for mediumwave and a 100 mtr longwire.
So he did. Mr Magic proved himself once again and made me a superb medium wave
16/1 balun. On top of that I was lucky enough (by chance) to improve performance
on some of the lower frequencies on short-wave. When it comes to baluns, I have
found home...
G whip Receive Antenna
Having been given excellent reports on your G
Whip
receive antenna by a VK3 friend who bought one recently I would also like to buy
one.
Please advise on the availability and cost including postage to Australia. Best
wishes Frank Holden VK3JFH
Greetings,
I have finally got around to doing a proper side by side test on the antenna I
purchased from you earlier this year. I used my Kenwood R5000 connected
through a Diamond CX310 switch to the the G Whip RX, an AOR - 7000 , and a
simple six metre vertical length of wire. The 20 frequencies used
ranged from MW broadcast up to 17.895 MHz. While the AOR7000 performed
a bit better than the vertical wire the Gwhip was invariably at least 2 S points
higher and on a few occasions as much as 3 or 4 S points greater than
either of them. The only area where they all performed equally was around 13.900
to 14.300.
I am very happy with my purchase..............Best wishes..................Frank
Holden..................VK3JFH
G WHIP RECEIVE ANTENNA REPORT:
Read the report from Stefan SM4KAS on G Whips receive antenna, this unit uses 6 very special cores and PTFE wire to produce the 12/1 magnetic balun, the high impedance of the 20 mtr kevlar wire is matched down to 50 ohms producing a superb receive antenna.